I like having redundancy — if one provider were to go down or drastically change rates it would be trivial for me to migrate — but if I were starting Buttondown from scratch I would likely just have everything run through Postmark.
Undated living page (changelog to 2026-11): Buttondown lists every tool it pays for, including its email delivery providers and support tool. (undated page)
Mailgun was the choice I went with, and there are still many customers using Mailgun's rails who have custom domain records set up that I don't have the heart (or incentive) to migrate.
And life on Mailgun was good, for the most part. I sent over a lot of volume, and their pricing was for a while the highest single cost I incurred, but there weren't that many issues.
Buttondown founder Justin Duke on moving from Mailgun alone to sending through AWS, Postmark and Mailgun.
Every entry is a verbatim quote and a link to the public post it came from. Nothing is paraphrased. If it is not on record somewhere public, it is not here.
The verdict is what they actually said: loved and liked are explicit; recommended means they told others to get it; uses means they only say they use it; read is a book on their public shelf with no verdict; mixed and disliked are kept too.
A dashed affiliate link, sponsored or their own label means the post disclosed a relationship. It is shown, never hidden.
The shading behind a date shows how dated a recommendation is for its kind of thing.
The shading behind a date shows how dated a recommendation is, for its kind of thing. Fully green is recent. It drains a quarter at a time as the post gets older, and is empty once it reads as dated.
What counts as old depends on the thing. A laptop praised four years ago has been replaced twice; a book loved twenty years ago is probably still loved. The shading is gone after about:
Hardware, services4 years
Software5 years
Podcasts, courses, other8 years
Books25 years
Stripes mean the post carries no date and the date shown is an estimate. No date at all, no shading.